Continue to Site

Welcome to our site!

Electro Tech is an online community (with over 170,000 members) who enjoy talking about and building electronic circuits, projects and gadgets. To participate you need to register. Registration is free. Click here to register now.

  • Welcome to our site! Electro Tech is an online community (with over 170,000 members) who enjoy talking about and building electronic circuits, projects and gadgets. To participate you need to register. Registration is free. Click here to register now.

Switching Inductive Loads

Status
Not open for further replies.

Straffan

New Member
Hi All

Can anyone shed any light on avoiding inductive spikes when switching inductive loads with a triac. I understand that these voltage spikes can jam triac's open or in worse case scenario damage circuitry.

Any help given would be much appreciated.

cheers
 
Those spike (if they are the ones I am thinking of) are due to stray inductance. Try to keep all connection to/from a power device as low inductive as possible (either by busbar or extreamly short harness lengths)


This is assuming these are the spike seen across the device at turn off.


Try not to use snubbers if you can get away with it. All they do is shift the losses (since the voltage spike will increase the turn-off losses). Try to reduce it by other means first.

Try improving the layout of the power components - you are usingf decent busbars for the DC-link arn't you?

Next have a play around with the gate-drive. If you can slow it down a bit (at turn-off) you will ok increase the switching losses of the thyristor but you will help it. - do not slow it down loads it still needs to be as fast as possible, just take the edge off it

with an improved power layout and a slightly slower turn-off then start looking at a RCD snubber circuit.

The reason I say try to reduce the spike by other means first is, every reduction in the spike you can do before having to resort to s snubber decreases the size of the snubber
 
Thanks for the replies. Just a couple of questions

In the attached circuit diagram, is C1 regarded as a snubber?

By busbar do you mean connector's and/or wiring or the rail on the circuit board?

Thanks
 

Attachments

  • circuit_3.jpg
    circuit_3.jpg
    23.5 KB · Views: 1,194
You need some noise filtering in that ther circuit.

simply put a diode across the inductive load matching it polarity.

Looks like you got the op amps set up for open loop gain, so any stray voltages will be amplified alot.
 
Juglenaut said:
simply put a diode across the inductive load matching it polarity.

Can't do that... The load is apparently an AC load - A parallel diode would cause a short circuit on one side of the AC cycle.
 
Styx said:
Try improving the layout of the power components - you are usingf decent busbars for the DC-link arn't you?

Next have a play around with the gate-drive. If you can slow it down a bit (at turn-off) you will ok increase the switching losses of the thyristor but you will help it. - do not slow it down loads it still needs to be as fast as possible, just take the edge off it

with an improved power layout and a slightly slower turn-off then start looking at a RCD snubber circuit.

His application is with a triac on a AC supply
 
Why is he using a TRIAC in an AC system then - it will not turn off?
 
Styx said:
Why is he using a TRIAC in an AC system then - it will not turn off?

It will turn off at every half cycle, at the zero crossing point where current will fall to zero (assuming no gate signal). Triacs are specifically designed for AC systems!.
 
true BUT what he doesnt say is what the load current is. The thing aboyut TRIAC's and THYRISTORS is there needs to be a significant period of no current flowing for them to stop ocnducting - I just dont think the zero-cossing in itself is long enough for minority cariier decay thats all
 
Juglenaut said:
Looks like you got the op amps set up for open loop gain, so any stray voltages will be amplified alot.

Yes, because he is using the first 2 opamps as comparators where you need the gain, but for any comparator with slow rising signal inputs, you need some hysteresis to prevent multiple switching's at the trip point, as I have mentioned in one of my previous posts on this subject.
 
I though I posted something about voltage suppression using zeners, hmmm where did it go...Any who I guess I digress, I can't remember all that I wrote to many beers, mabey I didn't hit the submit button??

I do remember that I said I forgot that Traics and such use AC.

Ah well if you think zeners can supress these induction spikes then go here:

https://www.electro-tech-online.com/custompdfs/2004/12/1N6267A-DPDF.pdf

these are unidirectional so they can be wired to deliver in-phase current rated on both sides of the wave.
 
Styx said:
true BUT what he doesnt say is what the load current is. The thing aboyut TRIAC's and THYRISTORS is there needs to be a significant period of no current flowing for them to stop ocnducting - I just dont think the zero-cossing in itself is long enough for minority cariier decay thats all

The device will quickly self commutate once through zero due to the reverse current, with absence of a gate signal
 
Styx said:
true BUT what he doesnt say is what the load current is. The thing aboyut TRIAC's and THYRISTORS is there needs to be a significant period of no current flowing for them to stop ocnducting - I just dont think the zero-cossing in itself is long enough for minority cariier decay thats all

That's how they work!, the load current doesn't really affect it.
 
Nigel Goodwin said:
Styx said:
true BUT what he doesnt say is what the load current is. The thing aboyut TRIAC's and THYRISTORS is there needs to be a significant period of no current flowing for them to stop ocnducting - I just dont think the zero-cossing in itself is long enough for minority cariier decay thats all

That's how they work!, the load current doesn't really affect it.

Fair enough. I have never used TRIAC's
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest threads

New Articles From Microcontroller Tips

Back
Top