Microcontroller vs discrete component design

Status
Not open for further replies.
No easy way, it depends upon the project and available resources of the manufacturer.

Do you have a specific product in mind.?

E
 
First there is design.... You draw up a circuit that will do what is required..

Then you build a "one" off to prove proper operation.... Mod as necessary...
Then you have a couple made... Once you have your design working as per!! Then you compromise between cost and operation....

I could build my boards 10% cheaper... But the warranty would hit the roof!! There is always a central point between the two!!
 
It's a fairly simple PSU with 12V battery backup.
It manages the charging and discharging of the battery.
I have built and tested the discrete version on a double sided PCB that I had made. (no SM components)
I have used a dual comparator (LM393) for voltage measurement.
Features include:
> Battery charge indication (red/green led)
> Changeover relay for mains supply/battery based on mains availability.
> Low voltage cutout to protect battery when fully discharged (with built-in hysterisys to stop relay energing when load is disconnected & battery voltage recovers).
> Battery charge current limitation to prevent overloading supply.
I have used 13 resistors, 1 preset pot, 5 capacitors, 3 diodes, 1 comparator, 1 voltage reference IC & 2 transistors.
All voltages are < 15 Vdc.
 
It could obviously be simplified and made cheaper by using a micro-controller, but the main advantage would be the easy (and cheap) ability to add lot's of extra functionality.

If you don't want extra functionality, then I'd suggest staying with the comparator
 
A little hard to say without a schematic, but in essence you are thinking of replacing the comparator with a micro - maybe eliminate a transistor and a couple resistors. Probably not a good bet especially if you need a regulator for the micro.
 
One way to reduce cost is to not use thru-holes, as each hole adds to PCB cost. SMT would lower PCB cost.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…