Mr RB
Well-Known Member
For NigelGoodwin and Nsaspook, sure I'll agree with certain modern music that has a lot of extra-LF content the mono subwoofer is good enough.
But for a lot of really nicely mastered classic rock (60's 70's 80's) it was considered good form to master the kick drum slightly to one side of centre and the bass guitar to the other side. With a proper stereo playback the effect is very nice and gives a very clear effect of the band in front of you with the drummer slightly to the side and the bass player slightly to th eother side. And there's little ELF content as it would have been rolled off to suit good stereo HiFi performance on system of the day. You can hear the position of the instruments quite well and it is the way it is meant to be performed, so you can really hear all band members in their places.
Now if you listen to that music on a setup with a mono sub and no stereo woofers (or mono sub and reduced stereo LF as is common in sub setups) then the unfortunate result is the bass player and drummer are now mashed together right in the middle of the sound, and it gets murky and (to me) is quite a step backwards from a good stereo setup that has decent response stereo woofers.
In my opinion (again) sub woofers are a theatre device, fantastic for movies etc and pretty cool fun for "doosh doosh doosh" dance parties, but I would never say they are the best system for general listening to stereo music. Maybe I need to confess to being a "purist" and should be buying oxygen-free 1gauge speaker cables over at the audiophile golden ear forums...
But for a lot of really nicely mastered classic rock (60's 70's 80's) it was considered good form to master the kick drum slightly to one side of centre and the bass guitar to the other side. With a proper stereo playback the effect is very nice and gives a very clear effect of the band in front of you with the drummer slightly to the side and the bass player slightly to th eother side. And there's little ELF content as it would have been rolled off to suit good stereo HiFi performance on system of the day. You can hear the position of the instruments quite well and it is the way it is meant to be performed, so you can really hear all band members in their places.
Now if you listen to that music on a setup with a mono sub and no stereo woofers (or mono sub and reduced stereo LF as is common in sub setups) then the unfortunate result is the bass player and drummer are now mashed together right in the middle of the sound, and it gets murky and (to me) is quite a step backwards from a good stereo setup that has decent response stereo woofers.
In my opinion (again) sub woofers are a theatre device, fantastic for movies etc and pretty cool fun for "doosh doosh doosh" dance parties, but I would never say they are the best system for general listening to stereo music. Maybe I need to confess to being a "purist" and should be buying oxygen-free 1gauge speaker cables over at the audiophile golden ear forums...
Last edited: