Thank you for your comments.
"I think your Spice is looking at the input and not the output."
You are right in that the probe is seeing the signal through R4 and R3.
I put another resistor from R3 to ground (110k) and then the sim. said +- .5 volt.
I changed the battery to 15 volts, then 35 volts, then 1 volt.
The sim. still said +-0.5 volt.
Then changed the op-amp to MC1458. Still no change.
It looks to me that the sim. just does not work with op-amps out of the box.
I would have to set up the sim. parameters for every op-amp.
Can someone confirm that this program, as is, does not handel op-amp simulation?