Depends on your outlook, however a bldc with a controller in my opinion will be a lot more reliable than a brushed or even an ac motor, the controllers seperate or built in are usually potted - totally encased in solid 'goop' so water and cack proof, a low volatge bldc is pretty hardened against moisture too electrically.
If you want a mains ac pump then you can salvage one from a washing m/c, the benefit with these is that the impellor is usually driven by a magnet, so you can stall the pump without a burnout.