You have biased the input at 4.5V, when the input common mode range extends to only 3V. You should probably set the input bias voltage at about 2V.
You have a highpass filter (220pF, 10k) on the input at 72kHz. Your input capacitor should be at least 1.6nF, which would set the corner at 10kHz.
EDIT: I see why you picked the values you did. In the simulation, it works with them, and it doesn't with the values I recommended.
I'm not sure I would trust the spice model. You are clearly exceeding the common mode range by a large amount. You can probably get the circuit to work, but you should probably be prepared to juggle component values when you build hardware.