So what makes the delayed 555 output pulse different than the alarm output pulse? The alarm output pulse can activate the starter relay just fine.
Could you please be any chance update the diagram for me?
And is my circuit broken now? Since it won't output anymore on 12v, even though it seems to work perfect with 5v?
The delayed output doesn't have the current drive capability of the initial alarm pulse.
The starter relay requires far more current than a 555 can deliver.
A revised diagram has been posted.
Its possible that you have blown the 2nd 555.