DigiTan

Wikipedia says the self-resonance frequency (SRF) of an inductor is the point where it ceases to function as an inductor. Right now I have a 180MHz circuit, and a choice of inductors with SCFs ranging from 240MHz to 1.8GHz.

I'm guessing the 240MHz components are too close. In general, what SRF range do you shoot for if you already know your operating frequency? Two or three times higher?

__________________
The most-hated young engineer in America.
* AVR Projects
* Robot War: TI
* About

Hero999

What are you building?

If it's an oscillator then just use a smaller tuning capacitor to compensate for it.

You can figure out the parasitic capacitance by rearanging the formula for capacitance.

__________________
I also post at the following sites:
http://www.stop-microsoft.org http://www.heated-debates.com
Screen name: Aloone_Jonez

DigiTan

It's going in a tank circuit in an FM Transmitter. The vendor's impedance vs. frequency graphs didn't cover my inductance range, so I can't really base an accurate estimate off what I saw there. Until, I do I was hoping there might be some rule of thumb for avoiding low self-resonance frequencies. Like should I operate under half the SRF or something like that?

__________________
The most-hated young engineer in America.
* AVR Projects
* Robot War: TI
* About

speakerguy79

I would guess the SRF is a very high Q two-pole peak. As such, significant phase shift will be present +/- one octave of SRF. I would say at least a factor of 2 if phase is of any importance.

Mikebits

I do not know of any rule of thumb (how many rules can a thumb hold anyways), but I would say. just operate under the SRF with margin.

speakerguy79

How many rules must a thumb hold
before you can call it a thumb.....

audioguru

Just make your own coil with thick wire and air as its core. Nearly every FM transmitter project has one made like that.

__________________
Uncle $crooge

DigiTan

Well, only thing is I'm buying those surface-mount chip inductors in the size 2012 packages. I suppose I could sub a hand-wound one in the prototype. The others are using SMT inductors.

__________________
The most-hated young engineer in America.
* AVR Projects
* Robot War: TI
* About

Bob Scott

If it is a new design, why would it matter what the self resonant frequency is, as long as it is higher than your operating frequency. In a tank circuit, it's like getting part of your capacitance for free. I'd just check to make sure that the self capacitance is stable with temperature, and that its value is stays consistent from part to part and batch to batch.

Nigel Goodwin

Doesn't sound a good idea to use commercial SM inductors, use a simple handwound air cored coil.

Inductance isn't the only thing you need to be concerned about.

__________________
PIC programmer software, and PIC Tutorials at:
http://www.winpicprog.co.uk

Hero999

Exactly, I suppose the only problem is that the Q might be low if you're relying too much on the parasitic capacitance.

Calulate the resonant requency you desire, using F0 = 1/root(LC), then transpose it for C, make F0 the self resonant frequency and subtract it from the capacitance you desire.

For example, suppose you want have a 100nH coil with a SRF of 250MHz and you want a resonant frequency of 107MHz. Ignore the SRF for now and calculate the value of capacitor requred for 100MHz, 22pF, now work out the parasitic capacitance, 4pF so use an 18pF capacitor.

__________________
I also post at the following sites:
http://www.stop-microsoft.org http://www.heated-debates.com
Screen name: Aloone_Jonez

DigiTan

I'll probably just go with the 1.8GHz SRF inductor. I can still get an SMT model with a 5% tolerance. I can borrow a C meter, so parasitic capacitance isn't nearly as important right now as finding an accurate inductor. And incidentally, the 1.8GHz inductor has a higher Q than all the ones with the lower SRFs.

__________________
The most-hated young engineer in America.
* AVR Projects
* Robot War: TI
* About

Papabravo

And when this approach falls flat on its face you'll probably go back and wind an air core coil.

__________________
We never have time to do it right; but we always have time to do it over.

Mikebits

How many air wound coils do you see in a PCS cell phone?

@1.8 Gig the PCB traces become inductors. much care must be taken.

Mikebits

I misread the post, I was thinking 1.8GHz, but even 240 MHz is tricky.